By CurtisW1908, 6 Feb 2012 CurtisW1908 is a Roar Rookie

 

The intensity in Saturday night’s NRL All Stars game proves that it has its place on the rugby league calendar. The haters will tell you that the injury to Greg Inglis is enough proof that the game should be axed – which is total rubbish.

Played at a cracking pace, the 2012 version of the NRL All Stars game had it all.

Like caged animals hungry for blood, the players were finally released from the torment of pre-season training and given 80 minutes to blow away the cobwebs. They did that and than some to produce an enthralling game of footy.

Doubters of the concept will tell you that the game should be abandoned. That NRL trial matches are good enough and the top players shouldn’t play any footy prior to round one at all.

The problem with this is that footy players need time on the field. The injury to Inglis in the final minutes of the clash at Skilled Park is a travesty for South Sydney Rabbitohs fans. But that’s just bad luck. That injury could have happened anywhere.

New Zealand Warriors prop Jacob Lillyman will miss the start of the season after hurting himself in a trial Saturday night against the Gold Coast Titans. Injuries just happen.

 

NRL All Stars coach Wayne Bennett knew the Indigenous side would come out firing.

 

“I think the Indigenous team really came at us hard at the beginning there. Lots of passion and emotion was running through them” Bennett said.

“Thank God it ran out in the end and it gave us a chance to get back in the game.

“It was just starting to run out at halftime and starting to wane a little bit. We picked our (intensity) up in the second half and they’d fired all their bullets.”

The match exploded early with Jared Waerea-Hargreaves and Sam Thaiday (surprise surprise) almost coming to blows.

Waerea-Hargreaves was involved again after a lengthy break down the western side of the field from the Indigenous. The Roosters enforcer came over the top of Ben Barba who was already into touch. The fire inside the players was evident.

The altering of a number of rules saw the game played at a frenetic pace. With the referees restarting the tackle count instead of blowing a penalty, players were out on their feet.

The players themselves will tell you that the hit out done just as much as any training could have done.

Waerea-Hargreaves knows exactly what the game means.

“It was pretty intense out there. There wasn’t many words said – I just stood my ground” Waerea-Hargreaves said.

“They’re playing for their culture and good on them.”

That’s the whole point. This is a celebration of the Indigenous people. This is their night and anyone that still doesn’t believe in the annual clash are in denial.

Veteran back rower Nathan Hindmarsh turned the clock back with a strong performance in both attack and defence while Jamal Idris and Nathan Merritt were impressive for the Indigenous.

The Crowd Says (6) | Page 1 of Comments

• Greg said | February 6th 2012 @ 8:59am | Report comment

  Don’t axe it but definitely move it to the end of the season e.g. like the NFL Pro Bowl. Sides would be selected from teams that weren’t in GF. If it was on at the end of the season you would have the following advantages

  - Play the game on the saturday before the GF, so you have a full weekend of entertainment for people that come to town for the GF.

  - Players will have played a full season so they will be a bit more relaxed and look at the game for what it really is- a novelty. They will still be competitive (as they are in the NFL PB) but maybe enjoy it a bit more e.g. players with microphones, on the weekend Jamal Idris was not keen on talking during the game. In the PB players are more relaxed and even make jokes, it’s entertaining and enjoyable.

  - More injuries occur at the beggining of the season. And if there are any injuries they have the off season to recover.

  Just an idea.

  Reply

• GC Tiger said | February 6th 2012 @ 11:39am | Report comment

  I thought the game was fantastic. I attended the very first game and have watched the following 2 on TV and can can say that it gets better every year.

  Injurys happen.. GI and Tate are a piece of glass anyway.

  The powerplay was embarrasing and should never be talked about again but unless we try things we can never evolve.

  The 6 again can only work if there is unlimited interchange and we sore where that took the game after super league, athletes not footballers. Maybe if we tweek it so that it only happens if the infringement happens in the attackers half. That would speed up the game immensely but not over do it.

  Greg Bird again showed why I threw my Titans membership in the bin. He is the grubbiest player in history and then makes me chringe when he sulks about other players reacting to his dirty play. ie the Gallan incident.

  Overall the game was fast, intense and deserves to stay.

  Reply

• PJ said | February 6th 2012 @ 12:56pm | Report comment

  The All Stars match is a a disgrace. If it is to be played the NRL should push the Grand Final back a week and the All Stars match can be played that weekend. What it would do will allow the teams in the GF to have an extra week off to prepare, obviously no players from the two GF teams would play but I can’t see that as a problem. On another note as a member of the crowd on Saturday night I was disgusted to be sitting behind a young aboriginal gentlemen with his aboriginal flag emblazoned with the phrase “black power” across the middle of the flag. Could one imagine the out cry of I held up the Australian flag with the words “white power” written on in.
  –
  Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.

  Reply

• Phil said | February 6th 2012 @ 1:03pm | Report comment

  Why was this match only shown in New South Wales & Queensland?

  Reply

  • GC Tiger said | February 6th 2012 @ 1:12pm | Report comment

    Because Channel Nine are a bunch of W**kers and the NRL don’t have the balls to demand better.

    Reply
• 

  The Barry said | February 6th 2012 @ 1:36pm | Report comment

  I loved the game in it’s first season but have struggled to warm to the concept since.

  I’m not indigenous so feel a phony cheering for them but likewise I don’t really want to cheer against them either.

  Once every couple of years would make it a better spectacle than every season. I know the game means a lot to indigenous players but will it once they’ve played four, five or six of these games ? Wouldn’t it mean more if a player only got a couple of opportunities to represent over the course of his career rather than a game every season ?